Crust & Culture: Your Insider’s Guide to the Best Pizza Places in Charlottesville

Mamma Mia! What’s better than a warm, crunchy-on-the-outside, melty-cheese-on-the-inside, slice of pizza? Being spoilt for choice while picking one! Nestled in the heart of Jefferson Country, the culinary capital of Virginia, Charlottesville has an incredibly diverse pizza scene that represents a myriad of tastes.

From the rustic feel of a traditional Italian pizza joint to eclectic flavors that question conventional wisdom – No matter where you are from, no matter what your choice of toppings, Charlottesville promises a mystic pizza journey that ends in pure delight.

Let’s embark upon an exhaustive tour of the best pizza places in Charlottesville, one savoury slice at a time.

1. Lampo Neapolitan Pizzeria: Your Taste buds Journey to Italy

Let’s get things rolling with the best – the most authentic Italian experience outside of Italy right here in downtown Belmont. Lampo Neapolitan Pizzeria’s name is a nod to the mythical pizza-maker from Italy, Lampo, who crafted pies so perfect, they were said to have an otherworldly flare. Their dedication to the age-old Neapolitan tradition leaves a taste that is both ethereal and earthy, at the same time.

  • Authentic Italian Flavors: Lampo’s pizza is a by-word for uncompromising quality and authenticity. Their pizzaiolos follow time-honored Neapolitan methods with such precision, they transport your taste buds straight to the heart of Naples!

  • Pride in Ingredients: The secret sauce to their success, quite literally, is sourcing the best ingredients. Lampo uses ’00’ flour and San Marzano tomatoes straight from Italy to form the base of their pizzas. Layered over this is fresh Fior di Latte mozzarella, melted to cheesy perfection.

  • Timeless Classics: Standards here are anything but standard. Their Margherita D.O.P is a celebrated favorite, perfectly exemplifying Lampo’s dedication to tradition. Fungi lovers, make sure to try the Mushroom pie – simple yet utterly satisfying.

  • Location to Remember: Lampo is found in a quiet, comforting corner of downtown Belmont, beaming an inviting warmth that only matches the heartiness of the food served.

Word of advice: Lampo is strongly dedicated to local culture and being in the moment, so reservations are a no-go. Embrace spontaneity and prepare for a wee bit of wait time.

2. Dr. Ho’s Humble Pie: Daring Flavours that Defy Expectations

Dr. Ho’s Humble Pie breaks away from traditional pizza norms and ventures into inventive, exciting terrain. Situated a little off-the-beaten-path in North Garden, it’s a little culinary world of its own, always ready to surprise you.

  • Unique Twists on Ingredients: Where else can you find cornbread crumble or smoked blue cheese as pizza toppings? Dr. Ho’s experiments with rarely-seen but meticulously selected ingredients to create a culinary experience that’s unique and unforgettable.

  • Daring Dishes: From their iconic Bellissima pizza, which is a mix of sundried tomatoes, goat cheese, basil pesto with a sprinkle of truffle oil, to other unique creations like Pulled Pork BBQ Pizza, they consistently push the boundaries of what’s accepted as pizza.

  • Locavore’s Dream: Alongside their showstopper pizzas, they also offer locally-sourced salads and sandwiches. It’s a menu honoring Virginia’s vibrant agricultural scene, inviting you to savor the fresh produce our great state is known for.

3. Benny Deluca’s: Where Heart meets Art

At Benny Deluca’s, pizza isn’t just a business; it’s a brotherhood. Known as much for their massive Virginia-sized pizza slices as for their benevolent heart, they take community support as seriously as nurturing their yeast.

  • More Than Just Pizza: Benny Deluca’s creations feed the community in more ways than one. Their mission extends beyond pizza, with leftovers regularly donated to local food banks and shelters – a small step to reduce waste and provide warm meals for those in need.

  • Signature Pizzas: The signature Benny’s ‘White Pizza’ deserves a spot in your Charlottesville pizza bucket list. Their delicate blend of garlic and cheese finds the perfect medium between the strong flavors of garlic and the soft creaminess of cheese.

4. Christian’s Pizza: Platter with a Purpose

Christian’s Pizza delivers what every eco-conscious foodie craves – a culinary experience rich in taste and mindful in practice. Started by a University of Virginia graduate, Christian Tammariello, the restaurant marries the love for pizza with a sustainable dining approach, and the result is nothing short of brilliant.

  • Innovation in Sustainability: Christian’s innovative low-waste cooking techniques reflect their commitment to being green, making them a pioneer in Charlottesville’s sustainable dining movement.

  • Variety and More: Their menu is as diverse as Charlottesville itself, with a changing daily special, and flavors from classic Cheese and Pepperoni to exotic Chicken Tikka and Thai Chicken.

  • Plant-Based Goodness: Christian’s Pizza ensures there’s always a vegan pizza option on the menu, offering a safe haven for Virginia’s growing community of plant-based eaters.

5. Mellow Mushroom: A Visual and Gastro delight

This nationwide chain is more than just a pizza joint, it’s a celebration of the unconventional. Mellow Mushroom offers a vibrant, psychedelic ambiance which paired with their eccentric pizza options makes for a delightful and immersive experience.

  • A Feast for the Eyes: The cool, eccentric decor at Mellow Mushroom exudes an artistic vibe that’s excitingly infectious. Sip on their extensive array of craft beers amidst this artsy ambiance for a truly immersive dining experience.

  • Intricately Crafted Pizzas: From the richness of their ‘Holy Shiitake Pie’ to the freshness of their ‘Mellowterranean,’ every pizza is a sensory overload. Exotic ingredients, complex flavors, all baked to perfection on their stone-baked pizza crust – Mellow Mushroom gives pizza an artistic spin.

6. Firefly: Timeless delight with a side of Fun

Marrying culinary delight with entertainment, Firefly is a fun-lovers paradise, doubling up as a pizzeria-cum-arcade. This makes every order a double delight – delicious pizza and fantastic entertainment, all under one roof.

  • A Truly Unique Experience: Picture this: an assortment of video games, board games, and artful pizza pairings. It’s like being in a fantastic dream from which you wouldn’t want to wake up!

  • Specialty Pizzas: The spotlight shines on their ‘Ham-Figgy-Figgy,’ an indulgent mix of prosciutto, figs, arugula, and gorgonzola cheese. For those looking for a classic, ‘Arcade Style Cheese Pizza’ faithfully keeps the traditional flame burning.

To end, uncovering the “best slice” in Charlottesville is subjective, hinging on your taste buds and individual pizza preferences. Whether it’s the thin or deep crust that tantalizes your palate, the unique or traditional toppings you fancy, Charlottesville caters to it all. Every slice of pizza here on these streets is a cultural delight – it’s not just about the food, but an experience that imbibes the city’s rich culinary culture. Welcome to Charlottesville – where each pizza slice narrates a story, exuding various flavors, charming each of your senses. Palatable pleasures await, so get ready to indulge!

Lauren Critzer

I was born in Charlottesville, Virginia and after college, I moved to San Francisco to explore new opportunities and broaden my horizons. I fell in love with the city's vibrant culture and unique atmosphere, but eventually, I moved again, this time to Austin, Texas.

As much as I loved living in different parts of the country, having a baby boy brought me back to my hometown in Charlottesville, where I now live with my husband, our little one, and two furry friends. I enjoy going to wineries, taking my pups everywhere, and spending quality time with my family.

Receive the latest news

Get the Inside Scoop!

Charlottesville’s latest events and eats, straight to your inbox. Subscribe now!